The psychologist behind the vase

The psychologist Edgar Rubin (1886–1951) is remembered in particular for ‘Rubin’s vase’, a drawing that shows both a black vase against a white background and two white faces in profile against a black background. It is not possible to see both images at the same time; when one appears as figure, the other becomes the background.

Explore the book 'From Yeast to Universe'

This chapter is an excerpt from the book 'From Yeast to Universe – Danish Basic Research Supported by the Carlsberg Foundation: 150 Highlights from 150 Years', published by Strandberg Publishing to mark the Carlsberg Foundation’s 150th anniversary. The book offers a kaleidoscopic insight into 150 examples of significant and memorable Danish basic research activities supported by the Carlsberg Foundation over a century and a half. The 150 examples have been selected by 25 Danish researchers.

This psychological phenomenon, called figure-ground reversibility, illustrates how we always perceive a figure in relation to a background. With a little practice, the viewer will be able to switch quickly between the two possible images and thus alter the figure-ground relationship at will.

Rubin’s work attracted great interest during the interwar years and was the topic of much debate in the scientific literature. It influenced the emerging field of gestalt psychology, whose key tenet states that humans do not perceive individual components but patterns and wholes. Rubin contributed to this understanding but stood outside the established schools of thought and forged his own path.

While a student, he came into contact with Alfred Lehmann (1858–1921), who was a key figure in establishing experimental psychology as a field at the University of Copenhagen. Here Rubin encountered the empirical study of basic psychological and epistemological issues, a field that came to shape his career.

Between 1911 and 1914, he continued his studies of experimental psychology in Germany, including in Thüringen, where his work was focused on sensation and perception. This marked the beginning of a lifelong endeavour to understand how humans experience the world through sensory perception and how this experience can be analysed by means of systematic, experimental methods.

In 1915, Rubin defended his doctoral dissertation on visually perceived figures, which met with great recognition in international circles. The year after the death of his mentor, Lehmann, Rubin was appointed to the position of Professor of Experimental Psychology and head of the psychophysics laboratory. Here he combined his empirical approach with a broad interest in theoretical and philosophical perspectives on sensation and perception. Over the following decades, his work had a profound influence on the development of Danish psychology.

The Rubin vase illustrates the figure-ground phenomenon, as the brain alternately perceives either a vase or two faces, depending on what it interprets as foreground and background. Photo: kudou / iStock

At the time of Rubin’s research, the field of psychology was undergoing rapid change. By the late 19th century, it had detached from philosophy and developed into an independent empirical science, inspired by positivism and its emphasis on systematic observation and experimentation. True to this new scientific spirit, Rubin sought to use experimental methods to uncover how phenomena appear in the human consciousness.

He labelled his field ‘adspective psychology’, from the Latin 'adspicere', to observe. The term underscores that sensory experiences always arise in a relationship between the observer and the observed. To Rubin, experiences were never neutral; they were always adspective, meaning that they were influenced by how they were perceived in a given situation.

Grant

Grant years: 1924–1952 (first and latest) Purpose: Psychological research

During Rubin’s own time, psychology became more application-oriented, while he preferred to focus on basic research revolving around philosophical challenges, particularly from phenomenological philosophy. In his later years, however, he did take on other tasks as well. He further developed Lehmann’s psychological tests for pilot aspirants, introduced a new university curriculum for educational psychology and was a co-founder of the university’s clinic for paediatric psychology, which opened in 1950.

Rubin was also known as an engaging communicator in children’s books, newspaper opinion pieces and radio lectures that made psychology accessible to a wide audience. With examples from daily life and using everyday language, he was able to make the ‘figures’ of psychology appear clearly against a background that anyone could relate to. 

The chapter is written by Sarah von Essen.